ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks
I wasn’t going to touch behavioral as a topic again for a bit, but everyone’s talking about a recent story on Clickz (such as on Mashable, where I left several comments) I figured I would throw a things into the conversation.
While I am a huge advocate of the wonders of Behavioral Targeting, I have some issues with this concept aside from the privacy issues. In regards to privacy, again as long as it’s opt-out I don’t see the tremendous concern.
A BT network today generally needs to establish specific behavioral contracts with publishers to make use of their users. So if a network wants to gather behaviors from a major site (for the sake of argument) ESPN, they need to get a legal agreement with ESPN over the terms of use. ESPN will then set up the behavioral coding from the BT network and the network can begin targeting the ESPN users across any site they touch.
The ISPs in this case will simply catch the packets on their own hardware between the end user and the publisher (say in this case ESPN) and resell that to the advertiser. They will then pay whoever they buy the actual ad space from, but not the property that provided the relevant piece of data. The argument I assume being that because the transaction occurred on the ISP’s hardware they have full right to mine that data. The only disadvantage I see for the ISP is that one can assume they won’t be able to go to market with the name ESPN as a source of their behaviors, they can simply say, “Here are users who are interested in sports/sports related content.” A ‘traditional’ BT network will most likely provide the advertiser with a list of publishers that make up the population bucket they’re selling.
If I were a major content provider with a huge brand name (say an ESPN, CNN, etc), I would be a tad upset at this development. The ISP can capture their users with limited cost, buying remnant inventory from a ValueClick is dirt cheap, and yet the ISP can command a decent premium from an advertiser thanks to the potentially detailed targeting. If I’m a major brand, this lowers the value of my users by creating a place to get them dirt cheap. While a BT network could arguably depress the CPMs a publisher earned, the publisher has control to cease the deal and the receive an additional revenue stream (without using any inventory such that it’s essentially pure profit). ISPs can easily undercut both the content provider and the BT network by avoiding the second payment.
All that said, I can’t say if publishers have any significant leverage against ISPs here. With a typical BT deal, the BT network can’t use a publisher’s users without consent. Theoretically, an ad network could compile behavioral data of users across the network they show ads on, however by going to market with this product (especially if it lists publishers by name) the publishers within the ad network can simply remove the tags and refuse to work with them. As such the BT network is forced to seek the publisher’s opt-in. The content providers may not have any means to cut off the ISP (short of damaging their own traffic and existing revenue streams) and could be locked into allowing someone else to monetize their users.
I’m not sure what the solution is to this, short of forcing the ISP to go down the route of a traditional BT network. But forcing them to go down this route, by paying content providers for their users removes a good part of the competitive advantage the ISP has and probably makes the idea worthless. In any case it will be interesting to see how this progresses.
Share ThisTags: Advertising, behavioral, content provider, ISP, publisher
February 16th, 2008 at 1:57 am
Saveur’s 100 top restaurants -…
ORLANDO, Fla. — Walt Disney World has banned young children from its fanciest restaurant. Children under 10 are no…
February 19th, 2008 at 3:04 pm
Thompson: Neighborhood reunion a happy…
Its boundaries are fixed by the Michigan State University campus on the east, a freeway on the west, two busy…
February 23rd, 2008 at 1:31 pm
HughesNet Is The High Speed Internet Service Provider…
If you’re like a lot of Americans you probably have a real appreciation for high speed Internet….
April 28th, 2008 at 10:49 am
Very interesting thoughts regarding ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks. But would you like to submit comments and backlinks on millions of blogs automatically? Blog Comment Poster will do it for you. Blog Comment Poster will increase your traffic, backlinks and earnings dramatically! Sounds cool? Yes, it is… the best automated comments posting tool on the Internet with many advanced features
May 12th, 2008 at 10:39 pm
Post comments on websites automatically using automated Comment Poster software. Get thousnads of backlinks per day, increase your sales and earnings. Automated comment poster is the best way to build backlinks and promote websites automatically today!
May 14th, 2008 at 11:45 am
Did you try to run online business and failed? Your websites make only a few hundreds of dolars per month? Want to know how to make more? I will teach you how! AdSense Money Maker is the best software on the Internet today that builds Google AdSense ready websites automatically. It has slow building feature, lots of different templates, builds AdSense TOS compatible pages and is completely automated. You must see it!
May 23rd, 2008 at 9:26 am
I read similar article also named ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks, and it was completely different. Personally, I agree with you more, because this article makes a little bit more sense for me
July 8th, 2008 at 9:45 pm
stieff bear
August 8th, 2008 at 2:06 pm
Search Engines Parser is enormously fast, 100% automatic search engine results extractor you were dreaming about for many times. Search Engines Parser can extract results from all search engines at the same time, parse titles, descriptions and links automatically. You can specify which search engine(s) to use and what kind of data to parse. Search Engines Parser can output results to screen, export to MySQL database and write to CSV file.
August 13th, 2008 at 12:30 pm
Hey!, been surfing the net for Home Loans, Mortgage Rates & Refinance Loans and found your blog regarding ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks. You really know your stuff! I
August 13th, 2008 at 12:35 pm
You got a nice post on ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks. Really very nice to read and useful, thanks for the nice share.
August 13th, 2008 at 12:39 pm
Your website is beautifully decorated and easily navigated. I have enjoyed visiting this site today and hope to visit many more times in the future.
August 13th, 2008 at 12:40 pm
I can\’t agree completely on ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks any way you provided here some valid info, i am looking forward to surf more on this…
August 13th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
I found you on yahoo while searching for Best Personal Loans and Bad Credit Loans. I just Stumble it on Wednesday!
August 13th, 2008 at 12:43 pm
I have to say, that I could not agree with you in 100%, but it
August 13th, 2008 at 12:48 pm
Hello webmaster! I am thoroughly impressed with your knowledge of ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks. Your insights into this article about ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks was well worth the the time to read it. I thank you for posting such awesome information. I find it on Wednesday and very happy reading this……Investment Real Estate Loans Michigan
August 13th, 2008 at 1:01 pm
I really wonder how you could write a post like this on ISPs as Behavioral Targeting Networks. You really organized all those thing in a very fantastic manner. I really appreciate it….California Home Loan Mortgage Refinancing Sacramento